Good points, Valdis. Guess I was mostly just bitter about having beaten my head on the problem assuming that the -s switch was doing more than it really did. However, I'd argue that in this one specific case, i.e. a log statement referencing a non-existent source, destination, filter, etc. that it *is* something that -s should check for. After all, this type of problem *guarantees* that syslog-ng will not be able to start up if passed this configuration file. More specifically, syslog-ng does this sanity check before starting up. Why can't it do the same sanity check when doing a syntax check? Obviously it's a bit extreme to expect that passing the -s check will guarantee startup success, but I do think that checking for undefined references in the config file is an appropriate check for -s to do. Paul Krizak 5900 E. Ben White Blvd. MS 625 Advanced Micro Devices Austin, TX 78741 Linux/Unix Systems Engineering Phone: (512) 602-8775 Microprocessor Solutions Sector Cell: (512) 791-0686 Valdis.Kletnieks@vt.edu wrote:
On Thu, 13 Jul 2006 18:52:23 CDT, Paul Krizak said:
$ syslog-ng -d -F -f /opt/mpd/vtec/etc/syslog-ng.conf Error in configuration, unresolved destination reference; filter='d_syslog_pipe'
The syntax is fine, it's the semantics that's screwed up here.
You had a syntactically correct line that referenced a bad destination.
I believe that the -s switch should mean "if it returns zero, then when you fire up syslog-ng, it *will* start up and begin functioning."
No.
The -s switch *can't* guarantee that. Consider all the ways it can fail on the way up - everything from being unable to bind port 514 for listening to not being able to exec() the binary for a destination that pipes to a program.
It's even possible that if you run the -s as one user, but actually launch it as root, it will fail because it can't read its config file (consider a /etc/ syslog.conf that's on an NFS mount in a cluster, owned by a user 'syslog' and mode 640 - and the mount squashes root access to 'nobody').
------------------------------------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________ syslog-ng maillist - syslog-ng@lists.balabit.hu https://lists.balabit.hu/mailman/listinfo/syslog-ng Frequently asked questions at http://www.campin.net/syslog-ng/faq.html